Debate › Desistance · Last reviewed 2026-05-16
Desistance research
Summary
"Desistance" refers to the observation that the majority of children with gender dysphoria, when followed into adolescence, no longer have a cross-gender identification. Older Dutch and Canadian studies reported persistence rates of approximately 12–27%; the Cass Review notes that studies of children who did meet the diagnostic criteria found persistence of 10 to 33% (source). Later literature disputes definitions and methodological premises; in the cohort of Olson et al. (2022), 94% of 317 youth who had socially transitioned identified as binary transgender an average of five years later, while 7.3% had retransitioned at least once (source). See also /studies/steensma-2013-desistance/.
Key studies
| Study | Setting | Persistence |
|---|---|---|
| Wallien & Cohen-Kettenis 2008 | NL | 27% of the 77 children were still gender dysphoric (bron) |
| Drummond et al. 2008 | CA (CAMH) | 12% of 25 girls (bron) |
| Steensma et al. 2013 | NL | no overall rate in the abstract (n = 127) (bron) |
| Singh et al. 2021 | CA (CAMH) | 12.2% of 139 boys (bron) |
| Olson et al. 2022 | US (TransYouth) | 94% identified as binary transgender after about five years, n = 317 (bron) |
Points of debate
- Definition of "desistance": behavioural, cognitive or identity-based?
- Sample selection: older studies also contain children with "gender-nonconforming behaviour" without dysphoria.
- Referrals to the Tavistock GIDS grew exponentially from 2014, with a majority of birth-registered girls in the early teens; the Cass Review calls the current group a different cohort from the one in earlier studies (source).
- The Olson 2022 figures concern already socially transitioned children, a selected subgroup.
See also
- People register — Steensma, Cohen-Kettenis, Olson.
- Timeline 2013 — Steensma publication.
- International comparison.
- Steensma et al. (2013) — dossier page on the central Dutch desistance study.
- Inclusion criteria — how the protocol treats prepubertal dysphoria before hormonal intervention.
- Exclusion criteria — comorbidity as a factor in differential diagnosis.
- Detransition research — related debate on outcomes after transition.
- Cass Review (2024) — recent re-evaluation of desistance literature.
- FAQ · Glossary · For journalists.