About ยท Last reviewed 2026-05-16
About this site
Position
Dutch Protocol is a critical research project of Stichting Genderinfo i.o. We regard the Dutch Protocol as a dangerous development in adolescent care: medical treatment of minors with puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones on the basis of evidence that NICE (2020) rated "very low certainty" for puberty blockers (source), that SBU (2022) found insufficient (source) and that the Cass Review (2024) found insufficient and/or inconsistent regarding psychological effects (source). This site documents how it could come this far, what the evidence says about benefits and harms, and why several countries have restricted it since 2020. We are not neutral โ we are source-faithful.
1. Publisher
This site is maintained by Stichting Genderinfo i.o. โ a Dutch foundation in formation whose statutory aim is public information about gender care based on peer-reviewed scientific literature, official evaluation reports and publicly available sources. The foundation was set up in 2025 and registered in the Netherlands. The site is not affiliated with Amsterdam UMC, Vrije Universiteit, the Ministry of Health (VWS) or any government or university body.
Correspondence address and board composition are available on request via the contact page.
2. Our position
In our assessment, the Dutch Protocol is not defensible as routine clinical practice for minors. That conclusion rests on:
- The assessments since 2020 by NICE (very low certainty for puberty blockers (source)), SBU (insufficient evidence (source)) and the Cass Review (insufficient and/or inconsistent evidence on psychological effects (source)), and the Swedish and Finnish guidelines, which according to the Cass Review recommend medical treatment only within a research framework (source).
- The absence of any randomised controlled trial in this domain.
- The documented shift in patient population since 2014: according to the Cass Review the current group is a different cohort from that of the earlier studies, and the approach was extended to adolescents who would not have met the criteria of the original Dutch study (source).
- Environmental Progress's reading of the WPATH Files, that members know children and adolescents cannot grasp the lifelong consequences of treatment; of the members approached, one confirmed his own statements and another disputed the interpretation (source).
- The existence of documented detransition cohorts in which young adults report that their decision in adolescence was not well considered.
We bring this position not as opinion, but as the source-faithful reading of the available evidence. Anyone who disagrees is invited to consult the primary sources โ all citations lead to the original publication.
3. Editorial principles
- Every factual claim is supported by a Vancouver footnote with source.
- The claims of the original researchers are reproduced integrally (see /debate/response-vumc-amsterdam-umc/) โ and then weighed against external evidence.
- Independent systematic reviews (NICE, SBU, Cass, COHERE) weigh more heavily than publications from the original clinic.
- Opinion and commentary pieces are cited as part of the debate, not as factual source โ see /methodology/.
- Corrections are documented; "Last reviewed" indicates the date of the most recent check.
4. Conflict of interest statement
The editors and board of Stichting Genderinfo i.o. receive no funding from pharmaceutical companies, clinics, patient organisations, law firms or advocacy groups โ on either side of the debate. The project is funded from the foundation's own means. Conflict of interest statements are available on request.
5. What this site is not
- Not a government body and not a university institute.
- Not a provider of medical, legal or policy advice.
- Not a replacement for primary sources โ all references lead to the original publication.
- No pretension of neutrality. But an obligation of source-faithfulness.
6. Corrections
Factual inaccuracies can be reported via the contact form. Every correction received is verified against the primary source; if confirmed, the page is amended and the change noted at the bottom, with date.