Section II · Last reviewed 2026-05-16
Scientific basis
The primary publications that empirically underpin the Dutch Protocol, plus methodological criticism and replication attempts.
Summary
The evidence base of the Dutch Protocol rests on a small number of cohort and follow-up studies from the Dutch research group (first Utrecht, later VUmc / Amsterdam UMC) between 1998 and 2014, supplemented by international replication attempts. This section provides a summary per study (design, sample, outcome, limitations) and addresses the methodological criticism of Biggs, Levine, Abbruzzese and others.
Critical note
The primary studies in this section are — with few exceptions — observational cohort studies without a control group, almost all from a single research group (first Utrecht, later VUmc / Amsterdam UMC). The UK study by Carmichael et al. (2021), the only formal attempt to replicate the Dutch design, found according to the Cass Review no change in gender dysphoria and did not replicate the improvement in mental health of the Dutch study (source). NICE (2020) rated the certainty of the evidence for puberty blockers on the main outcomes as "very low" using GRADE (source); the York reviews for the Cass Review found one high-quality study per review (source), and SBU (2022) found the evidence insufficient to assess the effects (source).1
Subpages
- Cohen-Kettenis & van Goozen 1998 — first case report
- Delemarre & Cohen-Kettenis 2006 — protocol description
- de Vries et al. 2011 — first follow-up
- de Vries et al. 2014 — the "Amsterdam study"
- Steensma et al. 2013 — desistance in children
- Follow-up studies overview
- Methodological criticism — Biggs, Levine, Abbruzzese
- Sample size and attrition
- Replication attempts
- WPATH SOC and the Dutch Protocol
Related
- People index — who the authors are.
- Original publications — chronological list with PMID.
- Timeline — publications in chronological context.
- Evaluations — what independent evaluators concluded about this evidence.
- FAQ · Glossary
Footnotes
- Taylor J, Mitchell A, Hall R, et al. Interventions to suppress puberty in adolescents experiencing gender dysphoria. Arch Dis Child. 2024 (University of York / Cass Review systematic review).