International โ€บ Spread ยท Last reviewed 2026-05-16

Spread of the Dutch Protocol

Summary

The Dutch Protocol spread internationally through guidelines and clinical services, among them the Endocrine Society guideline (2009, revised in 2017) and the WPATH Standards of Care (SOC-7, 2012). According to the Cass Review, early versions of the Endocrine Society guideline and WPATH SOC-7 influenced almost all other guidelines (source). In the UK, the approach to treatment at the Tavistock GIDS changed with the emergence of the Dutch Protocol, and in 2011 puberty blockers were trialled in the early intervention study (source).

1. Key dates

YearEvent
2006Delemarre & Cohen-Kettenis publish protocol
2009Endocrine Society Clinical Practice Guideline
2011Tavistock GIDS starts early-intervention pilot
2012WPATH SOC-7
2014De Vries et al.: follow-up of the first Dutch cohort in young adulthood
2017Endocrine Society revision
2019Quality Standard Transgender Care โ€“ Somatic (NL)
2022WPATH SOC-8

2. Why did it spread so quickly?

Several factors are mentioned in the literature:

  • According to Biggs (2023), the Dutch outcomes shortly after surgery appeared positive, but they rested on a small number of observations and measures of gender dysphoria that are hard to compare (source).
  • The authors published positive outcomes in influential journals (Pediatrics, J Sex Med).
  • International endocrinology and transgender organisations adopted it in their guidelines.
  • From 2014 referrals to the UK's GIDS grew exponentially, with a majority of birth-registered females in their early teens (source).

3. Deviation in implementation

According to the Cass Review (2024), the approach was extended to a broader group of adolescents who would not have met the criteria of the original Dutch study, and the original Dutch group had fewer co-occurring psychological problems (about 33 percent) than the young people referred in Finland and the UK (source).1

Critical note

The main evidence for the Dutch Protocol came from a longitudinal study of 70 adolescents, of whom 55 took part in the final measurement (source). Later UK studies gave a mixed picture: Carmichael et al. (2021) did not find the improvement in mental health that the original Dutch study found (source), and the Cass Review notes that both studies found no change in gender dysphoria (source), whereas Costa et al. (2015, 201 adolescents) found improved psychosocial functioning after psychological support and, more strongly, after 12 months of puberty suppression (source).2

See also

Footnotes

  1. Cass H. Independent review of gender identity services for children and young people: final report. NHS England; 2024.
  2. Biggs M. J Sex Marital Ther. 2023;49(4):348โ€“68.