Protocol β€Ί Changes Β· Last reviewed 2026-05-16

Changes over time

Summary

The Dutch Protocol has had several documented revisions: the case report of 1998, the formal codification by Delemarre & Cohen-Kettenis in 2006, the Endocrine Society guideline of 2009 (revised in 2017) and the Dutch Quality Standard of 2018. From 2020 various countries have introduced substantial departures from the original protocol after systematic evidence reviews.

Chronological overview

YearDocument / eventChange
Before 1998First GnRHa treatment (Utrecht)Clinical introduction
1998Cohen-Kettenis & van Goozen, case reportFirst publication
2006Delemarre & Cohen-Kettenis (Eur J Endocrinol)Formalisation: Tanner-2, age 16, age 18
2009Endocrine Society guidelineInternational codification
2011de Vries et al., first cohort (n=70)First cohort publication
2014de Vries et al., cohort study (n=55)Central empirical publication
2017Endocrine Society revision"< 16 years" hormones possible in selected cases
2018Quality Standard Transgender Care (NL)National quality standard adopted (published 2019)
2022SBU (Sweden)Evidence insufficient to assess the effects of hormone treatment
2024Cass Review (UK)NHS England: puberty blockers no longer routinely available

Main substantive changes

  • 1998 β†’ 2006: transition from case material to standardised criteria.
  • 2006 β†’ 2017: opening for cross-sex hormones under age 16 in selected cases (Endocrine Society; see WPATH SOC).
  • 2017 β†’ 2024: several countries (Sweden, Finland, UK) introduce restrictions on GnRHa outside research settings, and in 2023 the Norwegian commission Ukom recommends classifying such treatment as experimental (source).

Critical note

Several changes in this overview widened the scope of the protocol (for example hormones before age 16 under the 2017 Endocrine Society guideline), while the evaluations from 2020 onward narrowed it. The Cass Review (2024) writes that the approach was extended to a broader group of adolescents who would not have met the inclusion criteria of the original Dutch study (source).1

See also

Footnotes

  1. Cass H. Independent review of gender identity services for children and young people: final report. NHS England; April 2024.