Studies › 2014 · Last reviewed 2026-05-16
de Vries et al. (2014) — the Amsterdam study
Young adult psychological outcome after puberty suppression and gender reassignment. Pediatrics. 2014;134(4):696–704. Author: Annelou de Vries. Position in chronology: timeline 2014.
Summary
Prospective follow-up of 55 young adults who completed the full Dutch Protocol — GnRHa, cross-sex hormones and gender-affirming surgery. At least one year after surgery (mean age 20.7) gender dysphoria had decreased, psychological functioning had steadily improved and well-being was similar to or better than that of same-age young adults in the general population (source).
1. Design
| Type | Prospective cohort study |
|---|---|
| Sample T0 | n = 70 |
| Sample T2 | n = 55 (22 transwomen / 33 transmen) |
| Attrition | 15 of the 70 did not take part in T2 |
| Measurement points | T0 (pre-GnRHa), T1 (start of hormones), T2 (≥ 1 yr post-operative) |
2. Main outcomes
- Gender dysphoria had decreased at T2.
- Psychological functioning (measured on body image, depression and anxiety, among others) had steadily improved.
- Well-being similar to or better than that of same-age young adults in the general population.
3. Limitations of the design
- No control group: outcomes were compared with same-age young adults in the general population.
- 15 of the 70 participants did not take part in the final assessment.
- The final assessment took place at least one year after surgery.
4. Later criticism
The research behind the Dutch protocol has been criticised methodologically, among others by Michael Biggs (Oxford; Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy, 2023; source). See /studies/methodological-criticism/. The Cass Review (2024) calls the research on care for this group of young people "an area of remarkably weak evidence".1
See also
- People register — Annelou de Vries, Michael Biggs.
- Timeline 2014 — publication in chronological context.
- Previous publication: de Vries 2011 — first follow-up.
- Detailed attrition analysis (15 of 70): Sample size and attrition.
- Methodological re-evaluation: Biggs 2023, Methodological criticism.
- Replication problems: Replication attempts, Tavistock GIDS (UK).
- Systematic evaluation: Cass Review 2024, SBU 2022.
- Broader context: Follow-up studies overview.
- FAQ · Glossary.
Footnotes
- Cass H. Independent review of gender identity services for children and young people: final report. NHS England; April 2024, foreword (source).