Evaluations › Levine · Last reviewed 2026-05-16

Levine et al. — critiques

Summary

Stephen B. Levine MD (Case Western Reserve University) co-authored two articles in the Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy: one arguing that the interventions rest on very low-quality evidence and need a properly conducted informed consent process (source 2022), and one arguing that the two Dutch studies are methodologically flawed and not applicable to the current group of adolescents (source 2023).

Key publications

  • Levine SB, Abbruzzese E, Mason JW. Reconsidering informed consent for trans-identified children, adolescents, and young adults. J Sex Marital Ther. 2022;48(7):706–27.
  • Abbruzzese E, Levine SB, Mason JW. The myth of "reliable research" in pediatric gender medicine. J Sex Marital Ther. 2023;49(6):673–99.
  • Levine SB. Reflections on the clinician's role with individuals who self-identify as transgender. Arch Sex Behav. 2021;50:3527–36.

Lines of argument

  • Informed consent: according to the authors, the risks are ethically managed through a properly conducted informed consent process that shares the hoped-for benefits, known risks, long-term outcomes and alternatives in a way that promotes comprehension; they write that this process is limited by erroneous professional assumptions, poor initial evaluations and incomplete information for patients and parents (source).
  • Generalisability: the authors write that the Dutch protocol is not applicable to the currently rising number of adolescent-onset, non-binary, psychiatrically challenged youth, who are preponderantly natal females (source).
  • Methodology of the Dutch studies: the authors name three biases: only the most successful cases were included, the finding of resolved gender dysphoria is attributed to the reversal of the questionnaire, and concomitant psychotherapy makes the effects impossible to separate from those of hormones and surgery (source).

See also