Studies โ€บ Replication ยท Last reviewed 2026-05-16

Replication attempts

Summary

Attempts to replicate the positive outcomes of de Vries 2011 outside the Netherlands have produced mixed results. The Tavistock GIDS "Early Intervention Study" (Carmichael 2021) found no changes in psychological function on GnRHa. Costa et al. (2015) found that global functioning improved after psychological support and was higher after 12 months of GnRHa than when only support was given. The Cass Review (2024) writes that the GIDS early intervention study did not replicate the mental health improvement of the original Dutch study (source).

1. Costa et al. 2015 (UK)

A longitudinal study of 201 youth in the Tavistock GIDS clinic, with global functioning measured on the Children's Global Assessment Scale (CGAS) every 6 months from the first visit. Functioning improved significantly after 6 months of psychological support (CGAS 57.7 to 60.7). Young people who also received puberty suppression had significantly better functioning after 12 months of GnRHa (67.4) than when they had received only psychological support (60.9) (source).1

2. Carmichael et al. 2021 โ€” Early Intervention Study

English uncontrolled prospective observational study (n=44, aged 12-15) of adolescents on GnRHa in the Tavistock GIDS, published in PLOS ONE in 2021. The authors write: "We identified no changes in psychological function." Data were available for 44 participants at 12 months, 24 at 24 months and 14 at 36 months; 43 of 44 (98%) chose to start cross-sex hormones (source).2

3. Review article (Costa 2016)

Costa, Carmichael and Colizzi (2016) wrote a review article in Nature Reviews Urology, not a cohort study. They write that the limited data do not allow a conclusive treatment recommendation, but that some safety criteria for puberty suppression can be identified (source).3

4. Cass Review conclusion

According to the Cass Review, the two moderate-quality studies that looked at gender dysphoria and body satisfaction, the original Dutch study (de Vries et al., 2011) and the UK study (Carmichael et al., 2021), reported no change in either. The improvement in mental health found in the Dutch study was not replicated in the GIDS study.

โ€” Cass Review, April 2024, paragraphs 14.26-14.27 (p. 176)

See also

Footnotes

  1. Costa R, Dunsford M, Skagerberg E, et al. Psychological support, puberty suppression and psychosocial functioning. J Sex Med. 2015;12(11):2206โ€“14.
  2. Carmichael P, Butler G, Masic U, et al. Short-term outcomes of pubertal suppression in a selected cohort of 12 to 15 year-olds with persistent gender dysphoria in the UK. PLOS ONE. 2021;16(2):e0243894.
  3. Costa R, Carmichael P, Colizzi M. To treat or not to treat: puberty suppression in childhood-onset gender dysphoria. Nat Rev Urol. 2016;13(8):456โ€“62.