Protocol โบ Follow-up ยท Last reviewed 2026-05-16
Follow-up and aftercare
Summary
The Dutch Protocol included three documented measurement points: T0 before the start of GnRHa, T1 at the start of cross-sex hormones, and T2 at least one year after surgery. Standardised instruments included the Utrecht Gender Dysphoria Scale, the Body Image Scale, CBCL/YSR and the Beck Depression Inventory. Long-term follow-up beyond T2 was added in later cohort studies โ see /studies/follow-up-studies-overview/.
1. Original measurement points
The measurement points directly follow the three phases of the protocol โ see /protocol/the-three-phases/. In the follow-up study by De Vries et al. (2014), measurements were taken before puberty suppression, at the start of hormones and at least one year after surgery (source).
| Point | Timing | Content |
|---|---|---|
| T0 | Baseline, before GnRHa | Diagnostics, questionnaires, somatic status |
| T1 | At start of cross-sex hormones (~16 yrs) | Re-evaluation, repeat questionnaires |
| T2 | at least 1 year after surgery | Functional outcomes, psychological status |
2. Outcome measures
- Utrecht Gender Dysphoria Scale โ 12-item questionnaire, dysphoria intensity.
- Body Image Scale โ body-image-specific dissatisfaction.
- CBCL / YSR โ behavioural and emotional problems.
- Beck Depression Inventory โ depression score.
- Trait Anxiety Inventory โ anxiety score.
3. Limitations
The Cass Review 2024 rated the original study by De Vries et al. (2011) as of moderate quality, without change in gender dysphoria (source). The Health Council writes that long-term data are lacking and that the effects on cognition and fertility have been insufficiently studied (source). A Swedish systematic review by researchers including SBU staff (Ludvigsson et al., 2023) also concluded that the evidence is insufficient to assess the effects of hormone treatment in children with gender dysphoria (source).1 Later cohorts have introduced longer follow-up periods; see /studies/follow-up-studies-overview/ and /studies/sample-size-and-attrition/.
Critical note
Biggs (2023) argues that the outcomes of the original study rested on few observations and on measures of gender dysphoria that could not be compared (source). A Finnish register study (Ruuska et al., Acta Paediatrica, April 2026) found that young people who attended the Finnish gender identity clinics more often needed specialist psychiatric treatment for severe problems than age-matched peers, and that the increase was especially pronounced among those who received medical interventions (source). The original Dutch measurements focused on self-report of dysphoria and not on psychiatric care consumption.2
See also
- The three phases โ to which the measurement points T0/T1/T2 connect.
- Follow-up studies โ overview โ all published follow-up cohorts.
- De Vries et al. (2014) โ the psychological outcome study at T2.
- Sample size and attrition โ who dropped out of the original cohort.
- Methodological criticism โ among other things on UGDS comparability.
- SBU (2022) โ Swedish systematic review on strength of evidence.
- Cass Review (2024) โ recommendations for long-term follow-up.
- People register โ Cohen-Kettenis, de Vries, Steensma.
- International comparison โ follow-up practices per country.
- Timeline โ follow-up studies in chronology.
- FAQ ยท Glossary ยท For parents.
Footnotes
- Ludvigsson et al. Systematic review by Swedish researchers including SBU staff; 2023. PMID 37069492.
- Biggs M. J Sex Marital Ther. 2023;49(4):348โ68. Genderzorgen. Transgender care under scrutiny. Substack, 10 April 2026 (translation by editors).