Studies โบ Sample & attrition ยท Last reviewed 2026-05-16
Sample size and attrition
Summary
The main Dutch outcome study (de Vries 2014) describes 55 of the 70 young people followed in the first study (2011): 15 fewer, approximately 21%. Of the 15, it is documented that one participant died after surgery. Whether attrition was at-random or differential remains a methodological concern.
1. Attrition flow de Vries 2014
| Moment | n | Loss between measurements |
|---|---|---|
| T0 โ start GnRHa | 70 | โ |
| T1 โ start CSH | 70 | None: all 70 started cross-sex hormones (source) |
| T2 โ 1 yr post-op | 55 | 15 fewer than at T1, including one participant who died |
2. Nature of attrition
- One participant died from necrotising fasciitis after vaginoplasty (source).
3. Effect on outcome measures
Biggs (2023) writes that the favourable outcomes of the Dutch study rested on a small number of observations (source). If attrition is selective, for example because poorer-functioning participants are measured less often, T2 figures could overestimate the actual outcome; that is a possible mechanism, not an established fact. See /evaluations/biggs-puberty-blocker-overview/.1
4. Broader context
The Dutch Health Council (Gezondheidsraad) writes in its advice of 30 June 2026 that many studies have substantial participant attrition and limited follow-up, so that figures on stopping, regret or detransition cannot be established reliably (source). See also replication attempts.2
See also
- The study itself: de Vries 2014
- Methodological analysis: Biggs, Methodological criticism
- Replication studies with comparable attrition problems: Replication attempts
- Systematic review conclusions: SBU
- People register โ de Vries, Biggs.
- Timeline โ relevant publications in chronology.
- Original publications โ full bibliography.
- FAQ ยท Glossary.
Footnotes
- Biggs M. The Dutch Protocol for juvenile transsexuals: origins and evidence. J Sex Marital Ther. 2023;49(4):348โ68.
- Gezondheidsraad. Transgenderzorg voor jongeren. Advice, 30 June 2026.